Loyalty Gamification That Works: Lessons from Yu-kai Chou

In our recent session with Yu-kai Chou, #1 gamification expert and the creator of the Octalysis Framework, we explored how gamification can transform loyalty programs by understanding what truly drives human behavior.

Here’s a recap of the session’s top takeaways and how you can apply them to your customer journeys and loyalty-building efforts.

1. Build Loyalty on Motivation, Not Mechanics

Too many loyalty programs rely on points, badges, or arbitrary tiers, and quickly fade into background noise. According to Yu-kai, true gamification is not about adding random game elements. It’s about designing experiences for motivation.

I never ask: “Do you have badges?” I ask: “Do you make your users feel accomplished?” — Yu-kai Chou

That’s where the Octalysis Framework comes in. It identifies 8 Core Drives behind all human behavior, such as Meaning, Accomplishment, Ownership, and Social Influence, and provides a foundation for building experiences that feel rewarding on a deeper level.

The key is to understand how customers currently feel — and how we want them to feel. That’s when we use Core Drives to look outward and design systems that motivate specific behaviors.

Octalysis Framework and its 8 Core Drives. Source: Octalysis Group

Applying Core Drives: Real Examples From Yu-kai

• Tesla uses Core Drive 1: Epic Meaning & Calling to build loyal fanatics

• Porsche applies Core Drive 2: Development & Accomplishment to drive daily engagement in their app

• LATAM Airlines leverages Core Drive 6: Scarcity & Impatience for loyalty sign-ups growth

• La Quinta Hotel uses curiosity & unpredictability to drive hotel purchases based on Core Drive 7: Curiosity & Unpredictability

2. Intrinsic Motivation is a Key to Long-Term Engagement

Not all motivation is created equal, especially when it comes to loyalty.

Extrinsic motivation is based solely on rewards, milestones, or goals, such as points, discounts, or prizes, which may be effective in the short term but often lead to burnout or user fatigue.

In fact, studies show that when extrinsic rewards are removed, motivation often drops below its base level. In other words, relying on hot discounts or monetary perks can backfire, making users less engaged once the rewards stop.

Left Brain Core Drives. Source: Yu-kai's Blog

Intrinsic motivation is based on enjoyment and fulfillment that comes from the activity itself, leading to lasting relationships (perfect for loyalty and community building)

Companies should optimize for intrinsic motivation to make users continuously engage in the activity: "Right Brain Core Drives are good for keeping people engaged in the system. They don't want to grab the reward and run away. They don't want to cheat; they want to participate and engage."

Right Brain Core Drives. Source: Yu-kai's Blog

How to Apply

Let users co-create content, unlock missions with meaning, suggest improvements, or progress toward something greater than just a discount.

3. Use Core Drives Strategically Across the User Journey

Gamification is most powerful when it’s strategically mapped to key touchpoints in the user journey.

Yu-kai broke down how different Core Drives can be layered into customer journey stages to improve performance without adding friction.

Mapping Core Drives to the Customer Journey in Loyalty Programs

How to Apply

Before applying the mechanics, start by understanding which motivations are most important at each stage.

You don’t need to gamify every flow or interaction. But mapping even 1–2 key drives to a user journey stage can boost retention or conversion over time.

4. Good Gamification Feels Natural, Not Forced

Yu-kai made an important distinction: Gamification should feel seamless, meaningful, and rewarding, with no complexity.

Poor gamification adds friction, while good gamification removes it by making users feel like they’re part of something bigger, enjoyable, or valuable.

When done right, gamified systems can:

• Reduce decision fatigue

• Turn repeat actions into habits

• Make the experience emotionally resonant and fulfilling

How to Apply

When launching a new gamification feature, ask yourself: "Would I want to come back and do this again tomorrow?"

Conclusion

Effective loyalty isn’t about adding random game mechanics and rewards. It’s about understanding motivation and building systems that align with human core needs and drives.

Start small: map key Core Drives to each stage of your journey. Focus on what keeps people coming back because they want to, not just for a transaction. That’s how loyalty becomes habit.

Resources & Next Steps

Watch the Full Recording

Discover actionable tips, a detailed overview of the Octalysis framework from the creator, as well as inspiring cases from top brands like Porsche, LATAM Airlines, and Tesla.
🔗 Get the recording

More Resources

Explore Octalysis → Octalysis Framework overview

Discover best practices on gamification and loyalty → Yu-kai's Blog

Start Building With Enable3

Ready to turn theory into practice?
Enable3 helps to create loyalty journeys that users enjoy. Let's talk about building yours.